ISSN E 2409-2770
ISSN P 2521-2419

Analysis Stduy of Different Control Schemes Used For The Improvement Of Transient Stability: A Review



Vol. 6, Issue 10, PP. 333-338, October 2019

DOI

Keywords: HVDC link, Emergency control scheme, PMU, MPC, SIME.

Download PDF


In this paper various control schemes used for the enhancement of tranisent have been studied. There are two main control schemes used for transient stability enhancement: Prevntive controle scheme and Emergency control scheme. In this paper the main focus is on emergency control scheme. Further various emergency schemes have been presented in this paper like fast valving, braking resistors, fast valving in coordination with braking resistor, HVDC link for the improvement of transient stability. At the end of this paper a new control scheme has also been proposed in which PMU’s are used in coordination with HVDC link for the improvement of transient stability. PMU’s are used for the continuous monitoring of the system parameters.


Naveed  Ullah: US Pakistan Center for Advance studies in Energy, University of Engineering and Technology, Peshawar, Pakistan

Naeem Arbab: US Pakistan Center for Advance studies in Energy, University of Engineering and Technology, Peshawar, Pakistan

Uzair Muhammad: US Pakistan Center for Advance studies in Energy, University of Engineering and Technology, Peshawar, Pakistan

Tanvir Ahmed: US Pakistan Center for Advance studies in Energy, University of Engineering and Technology, Peshawar, Pakistan

Nisar Ahmed: US Pakistan Center for Advance studies in Energy, University of Engineering and Technology, Peshawar, Pakistan


Naveed Ullah Muhammad Naeem Arbab Uzair Muhammad Tanvir Ahmed and Nisar Ahmed Analysis Stduy of Different Control Schemes Used For The Improvement Of Transient Stability: A Re International Journal of Engineering Works Vol. 6 Issue 10 PP. 333-338 October 2019


[1]        P. Kundur, “Power System Stability       and Control”.  McGraw-Hill, 1994.

[2]         M. Pavella, D. Ernst, and D. Ruiz- Vega, “Transient Stability of power systems”. Kluwer Academic, 2000.

[3]       P.Gomes, “New strategy to improve bulk power system security : lesson learned from large blackout,”

[4]        Y. Min, K. Hou, R. Zhang, and Q. Tu, ÒA, “new method for generation shedding and load shedding in power system emergency control”. Ó in Proc. IEEE International Conference on Electric Utility Deregulation, Restructuring and Power Technologies, vol. 1, April 2004, pp. 210-214.

[5]      Chunyan. Li, Changhong. Deng, Y. Sun, and X. Chen, Ò “An on-line transient stability emergency control strategy based on PMU forecasted trajectory”, in Proc. International Power Engineering Conference, Dec 2007, pp. 807-812.

[6]      D. Ruiz-Vega and M. Pavella, ÒA comprehensive approach to transient stability control. II. Open loop emergency control, Ó IEEE Trans Power System, vol. 18, no. 4, pp. 1454-1460, Nov 2003.

[7]        D. Ernst and M. Pavella, “Closed-loop transient stability emergency control”. in Proc. IEEE Power Engineering Society Winter Meeting, vol. 1, 2000, pp. 58-62

[8]      M. Glavic, D. Ernst, D. Ruiz-Vega, L. Wehenkel, and M. Pavella, “E-SIME - a method for transient stability closed-loop emergency control: achievements and prospects,” in Proc. iREP Symposium- Bulk Power System Dynamics and Control - VII, Revitalizing Operational Reliability, Aug 2007, pp. 1-10.

[9]        R. Patel, T. S. Bhatti, and D. P. Kothari, “A modified approach to transient stability enhancement with fast valving and braking resistor applications”, in J Electrical Power & Energy Systems, vol. 28, no. 10, 729-738, Dec 2006.

[10]   N.fermendopulle and R.Ramshaw“Domain of stability of synchronous machine with excitation control-a cell mapping approach, Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 27, no. 3, pp. 173-181, Aug 1993.

[11]   D. K. Reitan and N. Ramarao, “A method of improving transient stability by bang-bang control of tie-line reactance”, IEEE Trans Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. PAS-93, no. 1, pp. 303-311, Jan 1974.

[12]   D. Ernst, M. Glavic, F. Capitanescu, and L. Wehenkel, “Reinforcement learning versus model predictive control: a comparison on a power system problem,” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics - Part B: Cybernetics, vol. 39, pp. 517–529, April 2009.

[13]   M. Larsson, D. Hill, and G. Olsson, “Emergency voltage control using search and predictive control,” International Journal of Power and Energy Systems, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 121–130, 2002.

[14]   B. Otomega, A. Marinakis, M. Glavic, and T. Van Cutsem, “Model predictive control to alleviate thermal overloads,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, vol. 22, pp. 1384–1385, August 2007.

[15]   J. Ford, G. Ledwich, and Z. Dong, “Efficient and robust model predictive control for first swing transient stability of power systems using flexible ac transmission systems devices,” IET Proceedings on Generation, Transmission, and Distribution, vol. 2, no. 5, pp. 731–742, 2008.

[16]   Y.Phulpin, J.Hazra, D.Ernst, “Model predictive control of HVDC power flow to improve transient stability in power system”, Smart grid communications, 2011

[17]   C. Li, C. Deng, Y. Sun, and X. Chen, Ò “An on-line transient stability emergency control strategy based on PMU forecasted trajectory”, in Proc. International Power Engineering Conference, Dec 2007, pp. 807-812.

[18]   Y.Xue, “practically negative effects of emergency controls”, in proc.1997 IFAC/CIGRE symposium on control of power system and power plants, p.134-138.

[19]   M. Pavella, D. Ernst, and D. Ruiz-Vega, Transient Stability of Power Systems: A Unified Approach to Assessment and Control. Norwell, MA: Kluwer, 2000.

[20]   L. Wehenkel, “Emergency control and its strategies,” in Proc. Power Syst. Comput. Conf., vol. 1, Trondheim, Norway, June 28–July 2, 1999, pp. 35–48

[21]   Daniel Ruiz-Vega, Mania Pavella, “A Comprehensive Approach to Transient Stability Control: Part II—Open Loop Emergency Control”, IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, VOL. 18, NO. 4, NOVEMBER 2003.

[22]   D. Ruiz-Vega and M. Pavella, “A comprehensive approach to transient stability control—Part 1: near-optimal preventive control,” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 18, pp. 1446–1453, Nov. 2003.

[23]   D. Ruiz-Vega, “Dynamic Security Assessment and Control: Transient and Small Signal Stability,” Ph.D. dissertation, Univ. Liege, Liege, Belgium, 2002.

[24]   Y, Zhang, L. Wehenkel and M. Pavella. .A Method for Real-Time Transient Stability Emergency Control, Proc. of CPSP97, I FAC/CIGRE Symp. On Control of Power Systems and Power Plants, August 1997, Beijing, China, pp. 673-678.

[25]   D. Ernst, A. Bettiol, Y. Zhang, L. Wehenkel and M. Pavella. .Real Time Transient Stability Emergency Control of the South- Southeast Brazilian System., SEPOPE, Salvador, Brazil, May 1998, (Invited paper, IP044).

[26]   D. Ernst, M. Pavella, .Closed-Loop Transient Stability Emergency Control, Proc. of IEEE/PES Winter Meeting, Singapore, 2000.

[27]   Duniel Ruiz- Vega, Mevludin Glavic, Damien Ernst “transient stability emergency control combining open loop and closed loop techniques”, 

[28]   J.Hazra, Y.Phulpin, D.Ernst, “HVDC control strategies to improve transient stability in interconnected power system”, Power Tech, IEEE Busharest pp.1-6 oct. 2009.

[29]   Duniel Ruiz-Vega, Louis Wehenkel, Damien Ernst, Alejandro Pizano-Martinez and Claudio R. Fuerte-Esquivel, “Power system transient stability preventive and emergency control, chapter 5”.

[30]   Duniel Ruiz- Vega, Mevludin Glavic, Damien Ernst “transient stability emergency control combining open loop and closed loop techniques”, 

[31]   Pavella M, Ruiz-Vega D, and al. SIME: A Comprehensive Approach to Transient Stability. Real-Time Stability Assessment in Modern Power System Control Centers, John Wiley & Sons, Inc 2008; 353-400.

[32]   Pavella, M., D. Ernst, and al. Transient Stability of Power Systems: A Unified Approach to Assessment and Control, Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000.

[33]   Youcef Oubbati, Salem Arif, “Securing transient stability Assessment Using Single Machine Equivalent Method”, Electrical Engineering (ICEE), pp. 1-4, Dec 2015

[34]   Durrant CW. Boiler response to partial load rejection resulting from System upsets. IEEE Trans 1982; PAS-10(8):2630–9.

[35]   IEEE Working Group on Special Stability Controls Power System Engineering Committee. Bibliography on the application of discrete Supplementary controls to improve power system stability. IEEE Trans ‘1987; PWRS-2(2):474–85.

[36]   Ramnarayan Patel, T.S.Bhati, D.P.Kothari, “A modified approach to transient stability enhancement with fast valving and braking resistor applications”, electric power and Energy system, p.729-738, 2006

[37]   Patel Ramnarayan, Bhatti TS, Kothari DP. Dynamic braking control strategies: a comparative analysis. In: Proceedings international conference on energy automation and information technology 2001

[38]   A.H.M.A. Rahim, A.I.J. Al-Sammak, “Optimal switching of dynamic Braking resistor, reactor or capacitor for transient stability of power system”, IEE Proceedings C-Generation, Transmission and distribution, pp. 89-93 vol 138 Jan 1991.

[39]   Riya Saluja, Mohd. Hasan Ali, “Novel Braking resistor models for transient stability enhancement in power grid system”, Innovative Smart Grid Technologies (ISGT), April 2013

[40]   Al-Azzawi FJ, Omar F. Dynamic brake switching time in multimachine Power system during emergency: Proceeding of the 24th University power engineering conference, Belfast, Britain, September 1989. p. 101–6.

[41]   Al-Azzawi FJ, Al-Wafi NM, Jassim AK, Omar F. Braking resistorsize, switching instants and assessment of power system transient stability by direct methods. J Inst Engrs (India) 1995;76-175–80.

[42]   Patel, Ram Narayan. Bhatti, T.S. Kothari, D.P. “Improvement of Power System Transient Stability using Fast Valvings: A Review”, Electric Power Components and Systems, P-927-938, Nov 30, 2010

[43]   A.H.M.A. Rahim,  A.I.J. Al-Sammak, “Optimal switching of dynamics braking resistor, reactor, or capacitor for transient stability of power system”, IEE proceeding C-Generation, Transmission and Distribution, vol 138, no.1, pp-89-93, 1991

[44]   G.G.Karady, M.A.Mohammad, “improving transient stability using fast valving base on tracking rotor angle and active power”, power engineering society meeting summer, 2002.

[45]   K.Koyanagi, T.Komukai, “a study of fast valving as an aid to power system transient stability part1. Some considerations of control methods for fast valving”, p.1-5, 1977

[46]   Shri Bhagwan, “A Review: High Voltage Transmission System”, International Journal on Recent Technologies in Mechanical and Electrical Engineering (IJRMEE) pp. 1-4, vol 02.

[47]   Vijay. K. sood, “High Voltage Direct Current And FACTS controller”, USA Kluwer Academic Publisher 2004.

[48]   N. Flourentzou, V. G. Agelidis, and G. D. Demetriades, “VSC based HVDC power transmission system: an overview”, IEEE transaction on power electronics, vol. 24, pp. 593-602, March 2009.

[49]   Chan-ki Kkim, Vijay K. Sood. Gil-Sood Jang, Seong-Joo Lim, and Seok-Jin Lee, “High Voltage Direct Current transmission” chapter 01 Development of HVDC     Technology,

[50]   P. Kundur, “Power system Stability and Control”, McGraw-Hill, 1994.

[51]   “Compendium of HVDC schemes throughout the world”, International conference on Large High Voltage Electric systems, CIGRE WG 04 of SC 14. 1987.

[52]   Brahim. Bekki, Mohamed Moujahid, Mouhamed. Boudiaf, “Transmission System Transient stability enhancement based on VSC-HVDC”, Journal of Electrical Engineering, pp. 1-6

[53]   Schetter F, Huang H, Christl N, "HVDC transmission systems using voltage source converter-design and applications" IEEE Power Engineering Society Summer Meeting, July 2000.

[54]   Y.Phulpin, J.Hazra, D.Ernst, “Model predictive control of HVDC power flow to improve transient stability in power system”, Smart grid communications, 2011

[55]   Javier Renedo, Aurelio Garci’ a-Cerrada, Luis Rouco, “Active power control strategies for transient stability enhancement of AC/DC grids with VSC-HVDC multi-terminal systems”, IEEE transaction on Power system, pp.4595-4604, vol 31, November 2016.

[56]   K. P. Basu, “Stability enhancement of power system by controlling HVDC power flow through the same AC transmission line”, Industrial Electronics and Application, pp. 1-6 Oct 2009

[57]   Y.Phulpin, J.Hazra, D.Ernst, “Model predictive control of HVDC power flow to improve transient stability in power system”, Smart grid communications, 2011

[58]   J.Hazra, Y.Phulpin, D.Ernst, “HVDC control strategies to improve transient stability in interconnected power system”, Power Tech, IEEE Busharest pp.1-6 oct. 2009.

[59]   Daniel Dotta, Joe H. Chow, Luigi Vanfretti, Muhammad S. Almas, & N. Gostini, “A MATLAB-based PMU Simulator”, IEEE.